Old-Fashioned, Unique Candies

16 products

The Original Chewy Peps - Peppermint - 16 oz bag

The Original Chewy Peps - Peppermint - 16 oz bag

Regular
$22.00
Sale
$22.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
The Original Chewy Peps - Peppermint - 5 oz bag

The Original Chewy Peps - Peppermint - 5 oz bag

Regular
$7.95
Sale
$7.95
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
The Original Chewy Peps - Molasses - 16 oz bag

The Original Chewy Peps - Molasses - 16 oz bag

Regular
$22.00
Sale
$22.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
The Original Chewy Peps - Molasses - 5 oz bag

The Original Chewy Peps - Molasses - 5 oz bag

Regular
$7.95
Sale
$7.95
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
PACK A TIN & SHARE SPECIAL! - Peppermint

PACK A TIN & SHARE SPECIAL! - Peppermint

Regular
$33.00
Sale
$33.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
The Original Chewy Peps - Cinnamon - 5 oz bag

The Original Chewy Peps - Cinnamon - 5 oz bag

Regular
$7.95
Sale
$7.95
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
The Original Chewy Peps - Peppermint - 12.5 oz Tin

The Original Chewy Peps - Peppermint - 12.5 oz Tin

Regular
$23.00
Sale
$23.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
The Original Chewy Peps - Cinnamon - 16 oz bag

The Original Chewy Peps - Cinnamon - 16 oz bag

Regular
$22.00
Sale
$22.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
Puffy Peps - Peppermint - 2.5oz bag - NEW PRODUCT!

Puffy Peps - Peppermint - 2.5oz bag - NEW PRODUCT!

Regular
$5.50
Sale
$5.50
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
The Original Chewy Peps - Peppermint - 12.5 oz refill bag

The Original Chewy Peps - Peppermint - 12.5 oz refill bag

Regular
$16.50
Sale
$16.50
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
The Original Chewy Peps - Ginger - 5 oz bag - NEW FLAVOR!

The Original Chewy Peps - Ginger - 5 oz bag - NEW FLAVOR!

Regular
$8.25
Sale
$8.25
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
Puffy Peps - Cinnamon - 2.5oz bag - NEW PRODUCT!

Puffy Peps - Cinnamon - 2.5oz bag - NEW PRODUCT!

Regular
$5.50
Sale
$5.50
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
The Original Chewy Peps - Ginger - 16 oz bag - NEW FLAVOR!

The Original Chewy Peps - Ginger - 16 oz bag - NEW FLAVOR!

Regular
$23.00
Sale
$23.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
Puffy Peps - Molasses - 2.5oz bag - NEW PRODUCT!

Puffy Peps - Molasses - 2.5oz bag - NEW PRODUCT!

Regular
$5.50
Sale
$5.50
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
The Original Chewy Peps - Peppermint - 12.5 oz Temporary Tin

The Original Chewy Peps - Peppermint - 12.5 oz Temporary Tin

Regular
$19.95
Sale
$19.95
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
Puffy Peps - Ginger - 2.5oz bag - NEW PRODUCT!

Puffy Peps - Ginger - 2.5oz bag - NEW PRODUCT!

Regular
$5.50
Sale
$5.50
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per